Skip to main content

Should national governments introduce minimum wages or should they leave it up to the market to decide on wages?

I support Market to determine wage rates. Facts and reasoning for justifying my point are following.
Minimum wage laws were invented in Australia and New Zealand for purpose of guaranteeing the minimum standard of living for unskilled workers. Minimum wage laws can set the minimum wages but can’t guarantee job. In practice they are often set for low skilled workers. (Gorman) . The International Labour Office in Geneva, Switzerland reports that some 90% of countries around the world have legislation supporting a minimum wage. The minimum wage in countries that rank within the lowest 20% of the pay scale is less than $2 per day, or about $57 per month. The minimum wage in the countries that represent the highest 20% of the pay scale is about $40 per day, or about $1,185 per month. (Smith).
For USA, Minimum wage in 1968 was $1.60 per hour while it was $7.21 per hour on a 1996 constant dollar scale and minimum wage in 1996 was $4.75 per hour. This shows that rise in minimum wages have not been keeping pace with inflation. (Federal Minimum Wage Rates, 1955–2013). Productivity of workers has risen between 1960 and 2000 but the wages have not kept pace with the increase in productivity. But US Government kept the minimum wage rates low in order to benefit the industrialist and petty shop owners. (Kulinski, 2013)But this benefit came at the cost of those who deserved to be receiving more. Although proportion of people working on minimum wage rate are just 5 percent of the population. (Smith) Hence there is no point in letting government set minimum hourly wages artificially low to benefit industrialist. Although the intentions of the US Government were not just to benefit but also to avoid losing jobs to foreign countries via outsourcing and shifting of factories to China due to concerns of high labour cost. (James A. Dorn, 2013).  
It is a law in most of the countries today that working below the minimum wage rate is a punishable offence. Hence even if someone is ready to work below the minimum wage rate voluntarily, he/she will not be able to do so. Hence to give liberty to people it is better to adopt market determined wage rate. Also there is cost of enforcing the minimum wage law which otherwise can be used to make poor’s better off by choosing market determined wage rate.
It has been proved for several countries over the years that minimum wage increase unemployment among the low skilled workers. (Gorman;Soundararajan, 2013). Market determined wage rates also encourages low skilled workers & students to acquire more skills and to employer an option to provide training and apprentice facilities for novice workers to enter lucrative skilled job market. (James A. Dorn, 2013)
There is always a fear with minimum wage laws that state may set the minimum wages at higher levels that labour supply starts to decline due to backward bending nature of supply curve. Such effects were visible in India when government started MGNREGA programme. (Vanitha S. M., 2011)

 Bibliography
Federal Minimum Wage Rates, 1955–2013. (n.d.). Retrieved November 10, 2014, from infoplease.com: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0774473.html
Gorman, L. (n.d.). "Minimum Wages", The concise Encyclopedia of Economics, Library of Economics and Liberty. Retrieved November 8, 2014, from http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/MinimumWages.html
James A. Dorn, R. R. (2013, April 18). Abolish the Minimum Wage Full Debate- Intelligence Squared U.S. IntelligenceSquared Debates. London, United Kindom. Retrieved November 10, 2014, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84t4pTUDFGo
Kulinski, K. (2013, December 12). Staggering Minimum Wage Facts. Secular Talk Radio Network . Retrieved November 9, 2014, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pc8xtbUhpQ4
Smith, L. (n.d.). The Minimum Wage: Does It Matter? Retrieved November 10, 2014, from Investopedia.com: http://www.investopedia.com/articles/07/minimum_wage.asp
Soundararajan, V. (2013, April 8). Minimum wages and enforcement in India: Inverted U-shaped employment effects. Retrieved November 8, 2014, from http://www.iza.org/conference_files/worldb2013/soundararajan_v9070.pdf
Vanitha S. M., P. S. Srikanthamurthy (2011). An Economic Analysis of MGNREG programme in Mysore district of Karnataka. Agricultuarl Economics Research Review, 24, 414-422.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Story of Inflation: An orphaned child

Inflation is the orphaned child of money. It has not been adopted by anyone so far and lacks culture and etiquette needed to become part of civil society. It's parent, apparently money who conceived it in unreasonable ecstasy and joy, abandoned it to be a wife of power in the society. The orphaned child takes unchartered journey in highly underscored manner. Its journey intends to inflict injury to the civilised society that hated him very much since being conceived and equally on his mother who abandoned him. The wrath of inflation results in decline in his mother's value, namely, money.  However,  course of its actions and its trajectory hurts the poor and vulnerable unreasonably in comparison to rich and powerful who owns & comnands his mother. This period of wrath further results in landlord, bankers & lenders, fixed income earners loses while tenants, debtors and speculators stands to gain.  The policy makers try to a pacify the aggrieved and orphaned child but f
Post a Comment
Read more
Where is my job? Every economy is required to maintain the full employment level of resources but very often economies fail to achieve it. The most common reasons are policy lacunae from Government. But what is unheard off is that irrational choices is the number one reason to name.This seems ridiculous at first site because economists assume rationality to prevail everywhere. But just think off a bureaucrat who lacks formal training in economics but is always tasked with preparing the draft of Government's proposed legislation/policy framework on creating employment in economy. The bureaucrat's lack of knowledge often reflects in the policy lacunae that governments make. The first one is that bureaucrat does not believe in power of market to allocate resources, including human capital, to various sectors/activities in efficient way and rather has firm belief that government's bureaucratic mechanism is the most efficient one for such task. This irrational belief is re
Post a Comment
Read more
Dear readers As I have been requested by my juniors from various campuses of Karnataka that I should provide reading and practice material online to all for benefit of juniors. Hence I am providing link to get material online. Following is the link of my personal website on which I have uploaded the book. http://gouravkumarvani.co.in/
1 comment
Read more